Main Menu

'This has to stop' warns Chamber chief

Skills crisis warning as migrants quit Britain

Neil Amner
Neil Amner: warning of skills shortages getting worse

Migrant workers are quitting Britain amid concerns over the Brexit talks and are adding to a growing skills shortage, says a Scottish business leader.

Scottish Chambers of Commerce economic advisory group chairman Neil Amner warns that this exodus of labour “has to stop” to prevent ongoing recruitment problems getting worse.

In the Chambers’ latest quarterly economic indicator, he says there is evidence that the low unemployment rate may be impacting on businesses’ ability to recruit the talent they need. 

“Recruitment difficulties are growing across almost all sectors of the economy and we are seeing businesses increase their investment in staff training, possibly to improve the skills of existing staff or to bring new recruits up to speed, who may not have all the skills that the business needs,” he says.

“Those recruitment pressures, underline the need for early agreement on the rights of existing EU workers to live and work in the UK and for the UK’s future migration policy to be driven by business need. 

“We are continuing to hear anecdotal evidence from businesses of a slow but steady drift of EU workers out of the UK. For Scotland, that has to stop if our current recruitment problems are to be reversed.”

The report, released in collaboration with the Fraser of Allander Institute, reveals a broadly positive story in terms of business performance across most sectors but accompanied by some stark warnings about the potential challenges ahead. 

Performance in the construction sector has improved since the beginning of the year, but concerns remain about the persistent negative trend in contracts from the public sector. 

Tourism growing (photo by Terry Murden)

Manufacturing businesses have again reported strong results, with evidence of a sharp increase in export revenues, possibly as a result of the exchange rate.  The tourism sector is also looking well set for the summer, whilst key indicators in the financial and business services sector, such as profitability and employment, have returned to their best levels for more than two years.

Mr Amner says:These are all positive signs in line with other recent surveys and data. They indicate that the Scottish economy will continue to grow this year.

“Businesses are, however, also highlighting longer term threats to success from factors such as falling real incomes and rising recruitment problems.”

The retail sector is considered most exposed to pressures on household budgets.

“It is therefore worrying that almost half of retail respondents are reporting a fall in revenues and profits,” says Mr Amner. “Supply chain price rise pressures will compound that issue. Consumer demand drives around three quarters of Scotland’s economic growth, so unless the recent falls in real earnings are reversed, there is a risk that the impact could spread to the wider economy.

“Although the survey results are positive overall, they are not wildly so. Corporate training investments are being made in the context of tight margins and uncertain times, exposing the punitive nature of the Scottish operation of the Apprenticeship Levy for those paying it.

“It is time for Governments at all levels to begin planning for the kind of country we want Scotland to be, and investing in assets like world leading digital connectivity to help businesses to grow, rather than placing further cost pressures in the way of growth.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked as *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.